hugo weaving infinity war

Original Red Skull actor Hugo Weaving was asked to return for Avengers: Infinity War. This Walking Dead actor had a major role in Avengers: Infinity War, but you almost certainly didn't realize it at the time. The Hydra scientist tampered with the power of the Tesseract and the Space Stone repaid him by teleporting him to Vormir. But Weaving didn’t play Red Skull in the Avengers movies. Instead, Ross Marquand took over the character in his new role as guardian of the Soul Stone. Hugo Weaving was asked to return to reprise Red Skull, that’s all the Russo Brothers would say. Close. The character was originally played by Hugo Weaving in The First Avenger, but the role was recast for Infinity War, with The Walking Dead’s Ross Marquand portraying the former Hydra leader. Captain America: The First Avenger star Hugo Weaving has … 8. It's as simple as that. Hugo Wallace Weaving (nacido el 4 de abril de 1960) es un actor anglo-australiano. Hugo Weaving’s relationship with the … That’s your entire high school. While the Marvel Cinematic Universe has proven to be an unprecedented success in terms of scope and continuity, things don't always work out. The Russo brothers also confirmed he'd been approached, but it was not … In Avengers: Infinity War, Gamora leads Thanos to the elusive Soul Stone. Hugo Weaving, Actor: The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King. Hugo Wallace Weaving was born on April 4, 1960 in Nigeria, to English parents Anne (Lennard), a tour guide and teacher, and Wallace Weaving, a seismologist. Hugo has an older brother, Simon, and a younger sister, Anna, who both also live and work in Australia. You can finally find out why Hugo Weaving didn't return as … Speaking with EW, the actor/impersonator went deep on his Infinity War cameo. 1. Warning: This post contains one minor spoiler for Avengers: Infinity War.. Hugo Weaving explains why he didn't reprise his role as Red Skull in Avengers: Infinity War or Avengers: Endgame, and why he's not coming back for Matrix 4. Hugo Weaving is explaining why he did not return as Red Skull for the Avengers movies and instead, was replaced by actor Ross Marquand as the voice the character in Infinity War … Avengers: Infinity War kept plenty of surprises out of the trailers, and easily one of the biggest ones was the shocking return of Red Skull, the villain of Captain America: The First Avenger. Branagh directed the first Thor movie … He was replaced by Ross Marquand for Avengers: Infinity War and Avengers: Endgame. Hugo Weaving - Avengers Infinity War Marvel Studios For the longest time, it seemed as though all hope of Hugo Weaving returning to the MCU as the formidable Red Skull had been lost. A subreddit dedicated to Marvel Studios and the Marvel Cinematic Universe! In December of 2018, Collider hosted a Q&A with the Russo Brothers about Avengers: Infinity War and they were asked if Hugo Weaving ever came close to reprising his role as the Red Skull.Anthony Russo said, “He was asked.”And now we know Weaving’s side of the story. One of the biggest surprises of 2018’s “Avengers: Infinity War” was when the Red Skull revealed himself on the planet Vormir, where he’s cursed in a purgatory state to serve as a guide to those seeking the Soul Stone. Just Jared: The latest in celebrity news, photos, and gossip in entertainment, celebrities, tv, movies, pop culture and more! He was nominated for a Scream Award for Best Villain for his work on Captain America: The First Avenger. Recently, Marquand revealed that, while he would love to continue playing Red Skull, the role is always going to be Weaving's to him. AVENGERS 4 directors The Russo Brothers have revealed why the Red Skull guards the Soul Stone in Avengers Infinity War and admitted Hugo Weaving was asked to reprise the role. Posted by 1 year ago. January 22, 2020 by Liam Waddington Hugo Weaving has said that while he would have been up for reprising his role as Red Skull in Avengers: Infinity War and Endgame, Marvel proved 'impossible' to negotiate with.. Weaving was the villain in 2011 movie Captain America: The First Avenger, and was all up for making a comeback in the final two chapters.. 2011–present. In the Captain America movie he was played by Hugo Weaving but Ross Marquand took over the role in Infinity War. The final battle between Chris Evans' Captain America and Hugo Weaving's Red Skull in The First Avenger is considered to be fairly anticlimactic by many. He is the recipient of six Australian Academy of Cinema and Television Arts Awards (AACTA) and has also been recognized as an Honorary Officer of the Order of Australia. Hugo Weaving has said that while he would have been up for reprising his role as Red Skull in Avengers: Infinity War and Endgame, Marvel proved 'impossible' to negotiate with.. Weaving was the villain in 2011 movie Captain America: The First Avenger, and was all up for making a comeback in the final two chapters.. In a movie full of surprises, none may have been as shocking to longtime MCU fans as the return of the Captain America villain and his connection to the Soul Stone. Marvel has been dropping hints over the last decade to set-up for Avengers: Infinity War. Imagine that. Hugo Wallace Weaving was born on April 4, 1960 in Nigeria, to English parents Anne (Lennard), a tour guide and teacher, and Wallace Weaving, a seismologist. This turned out to be reasonably accurate, although the Skull was more of a supporting character than a villain in Infinity War and Endgame so, what went wrong? People got oversensitive to his comments, but while he didn't want to come back to it, he said he enjoyed working on the movie. Avengers: Infinity War (2018) Hugo Weaving is Red Skull. Él interpretó a Johann Schmidt / Red Skull en Captain America: The First Avenger. Hugo has an older brother, Simon, and a younger sister, Anna, who both also live and work in Australia. One sneaky cameo has an extra secret. 1.2m members in the marvelstudios community. Sci-fi allows us to imagine what life would be like if robots took over or if we could fly around in cars. ... Infinity War" and "Endgame", claiming the studio tried to short change him. Su personaje ha sido interpretado por el actor Ross Marquand desde la película Avengers: Infinity War. Hugo Weaving reveals why he didn’t reprise Red Skull role in Avengers: Infinity War and Endgame. A whole damn school full of superpowered people and their un-superpowered friends. In an interview with Time Out, Weaving explains why he didn’t return: ‘Oh, yeah. The First Avenger, and Hugo Weaving decided he was done with full-face prosthetics, I figured the Red Skull would be quietly forgotten about. If someone turns down what is essentially an extended cameo role in what is going to be a blockbuster film, you can just assume that they made an offer and that production was unwilling to meet it. Alyssa Rosenberg. Hugo Weaving debuted as The Red Skull in Captain America: The First Avengers, but did not reprise the role for the character's brief appearances in Avengers: Infinity War and Endgame. Marquand certainly captures enough of Weaving’s voice and delivery in Infinity War to make this new version of Red Skull tough to differentiate from the original. After a few punches and missed shots of an Infinity Stone-powered weapon, Hugo Weaving's villain was largely the cause of his own failure. Like any school, there are … Ross Marquand went to play the role in Infinity War and Endgame ... Hugo Weaving explained why he parted ways with the Marvel franchise after … He reappeared in "Infinity War" … This was confirmed in 2018, when Weaving's character, the Red Skull, appeared in Infinity War and Endgame with Ross Marquand in the role. Hugo Wallace Weaving AO (born 4 April 1960) is an English actor. Season 1 As the Avengers and their allies have continued to protect the world from threats too large for any one hero to handle, a new danger has emerged from the cosmic shadows: Thanos. Captain America: the First Avenger: Directed by Joe Johnston. Im Marvel Cinematic Universe spielte er Red Skull in Captain America: The First Avenger. Science Fiction is based on our human understanding of science and technology, and explores ideas of time travel, space exploration, extraterrestrial life, advanced science, and planetary colonization. So. Hugo Weaving has said that while he would have been up for reprising his role as Red Skull in Avengers: Infinity War and Endgame, Marvel proved 'impossible' to … ... Hugo Weaving, who … Hugo Weaving explained why he did not reprise his role as Red Skull in Marvel Studios ... Infinity War and Endgame featured several returning favorites from past Marvel Studios films. Now, Weaving has revealed that contractual changes were the main reason he didn't return to play the character in Infinity War and Endgame. Hugo Weaving worked again with Richard … Hugo Weaving has said that while he would have been up for reprising his role as Red Skull in Avengers: Infinity War and Endgame, Marvel proved 'impossible' to negotiate with. Hugo Wallace Weaving AO (born 4 April 1960) is an English actor. While both Avengers: Infinity War and Avengers: Endgame would feature Ross Marquand as the villainous Red Skull, the character was first portrayed in 2011's Captain America: The First Avenger by Hugo Weaving. With Chris Evans, Hayley Atwell, Sebastian Stan, Tommy Lee Jones. He was voiced by Ross Marquand doing an impression of Weaving and his appearance was entirely CGI. Hugo Wallace Weaving portrayed Johann Schmidt/Red Skull in Captain America: The First Avenger. You can finally find out why Hugo Weaving didn't return as Red Skull in Marvel's Avengers sequels Infinity War and Endgame. Josh Brolin as Thanos in a scene from Marvel Studios’ “Avengers: Infinity War.” (Marvel Studios via AP) Opinion by . 17 Mind-Blowing Details In "Avengers: Infinity War" That Will Make You Want To Re-Watch It ASAP. Sky High, anyone? Hugo Weaving has been talking about why he didn't return to the role of Red Skull in Avengers: Infinity War and Endgame. Seven years later, in Avengers Infinity War, the Red Skull returned as the keeper of the Soul Stone on Vormir – but that wasn’t original star Hugo Weaving playing him. And by the way, that’s not Hugo Weaving playing the character in Infinity War. The kicker was that the actor behind the skull wasn’t Hugo Weaving but Ross Marquand. Captain America's biggest nemesis, the Red Skull (real name Johann Shmidt), was first played by Hugo Weaving. While he's a familiar character to many, Weaving did not return in the role. Hugo Wallace Weaving portrayed Johann Schmidt/Red Skull in Captain America: The First Avenger. “I think the reference they might have given is Yoda-esque,” Marquand said when explaining that the directorial Russo brothers wanted a Hugo Weaving impression that … The hooded figure is Red Skull (originally played by Hugo Weaving but recast with Ross Marquand for Infinity War), the villain of Captain America: The First Avenger. April 1960 in Ibadan, Nigeria) ist ein britisch-australischer Schauspieler und Synchronsprecher. One of the biggest surprises of 2018’s “Avengers: Infinity War” was when the Red Skull revealed himself on the planet Vormir, where he’s cursed in … Avengers: Infinity War is the culmination of 18 movies over the course of 10 years — a whole cinematic universe reaching its zenith in a battle for … Why Hugo Weaving Didn't Return as Red Skull in Infinity War or Avengers: Endgame. Just in case Avengers: Infinity War wasn’t star-studded enough already, Kenneth Branagh had a secret cameo. The handheld game Groot is playing is … Specifically, the last time we saw Red Skull, the Tesseract shredded him. ... Also different is the fact he’s not played by Hugo Weaving this time, it’s now Ross Marquand. Red Skull's return was an exciting and heartbreaking moment in Infinity War, but fans may have noticed that actor Hugo Weaving was no longer playing the character. Avengers: Infinity War is a 2018 American superhero film based on the Marvel Comics superhero team the Avengers.Produced by Marvel Studios and distributed by Walt Disney Studios Motion Pictures, it is the sequel to The Avengers (2012) and Avengers: Age of Ultron (2015), and the 19th film in the Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU). Wasn’t that a Disney Channel movie with Nicholas Braun in it? Avengers: Infinity War—A Guide to all the Cameos and Surprising Bit Parts. He was never going to come back. Hugo Weaving revealed that the Russo Brothers had reached out to him regarding if he wanted the role for Avengers: Infinity War, but Weaving declined it as the amount of money he was being offered was less than what he received when he first starred in Captain America: The First Avenger; an agreement that went against his initial contract. El actor Hugo Weaving dio vida al villano de Capitán América: El primer Vengador (2011), pero no repitió como Cráneo Rojo en Vengadores: Infinity War … Weaving at Sydney Film Festival, 2013. Hugo Weaving, who played The Red Skull in Captain America: The First Avenger, said a contract dispute prevented him from returning to the MCU. Archived. Instead, as we learn in Infinity War, ... And here’s the tell: it’s a great impression of Hugo Weaving, but Weaving was himself doing an impression of Werner Herzog in the role. It’s hard to remember every semi-hidden tip over 10 years, but we’ve got you covered. In the movie Avengers: Infinity War, Ross Marquand played the role of Red Skull, even though Hugo Weaving played the role initially in Captain … Avengers: Infinity War is a cinematic experience chock full of surprises — some expected, and some that come completely out of nowhere. ... Infinity War and Avengers: Endgame feel like—completely satisfying. The Skull's reappearance as keeper of the Soul Stone on the planet Vormir was one of the more unexpected and crowd-pleasing moments in Infinity War, but … 864 votes, 61 comments. Basically, Weaving wanted more money for Infinity War and Endgame than Marvel was willing to give him, and he walked away. Weaving says that while he was indeed approached to reprise the role, Marvel basically failed to abide by the terms of the agreement that was forged when he signed on for Captain America: The First Avenger. The process of redesigning Red Skull for his surprise appearance in 'Avengers: Infinity War' was quite interesting without Hugo Weaving involved. Hugo Weaving would have come back as Red Skull — if Marvel weren't so "impossible" to deal with. While Hugo Weaving had played Red Skull in Captain America: The First Avenger, it was another actor taking it on for Avengers: Infinity War and … Hugo Weaving previously worked with Joe Johnston in The Wolfman. One of Australia’s most respected actors, Hugo Weaving is known for his turns in some of the most successful movie franchises of all time. TIL that Hugo Weaving did not return as Red Skull for Infinity War or Endgame. The Soul stone was the last stone in writing for them to come up with. Weaving played a supporting role in Joe Johnston 's 2010 remake of the 1941 film The Wolfman, starring Benicio del Toro. Immediately after Wolfman wrapped in spring 2008, he returned home to Australia to film a lead role in the film Last Ride, directed by Glendyn Ivin. Hugo Weaving es uno de los… Here’s some knowledge for you: There are over 700 characters in the Marvel Cinematic Universe. Science Fiction is a genre that creates stories set in imaginative and futuristic worlds. Steve Rogers, a rejected military soldier, transforms into Captain America after taking a dose of a "Super-Soldier serum". Ross Marquand went to play the role in 2018's Avengers: Infinity War and 2019's Avengers: Endgame. Weaving has been busy with multiple projects over the past few years, in both TV and film, including the upcoming motion pictures Loveland and Lone Wolf. Avengers: Infinity War is the culmination of 18 movies over the course of 10 years — a whole cinematic universe reaching its zenith in a battle for … He was replaced by Ross Marquand for Avengers: Infinity War and Avengers: Endgame. Red Skull (Hugo Weaving, Captain America: The First Avenger) Marvel Studios. Hugo Weaving, Actor: The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King. The character first appeared in the Marvel Cinematic Universe in Captain America: The First Avenger as played by Hugo Weaving. No, he apparently kept to his word and so the part was recast. Hugo Weaving previously worked with Joe Johnston in The Wolfman. Avengers: Infinity War is a piece of entertainment that prizes scale over nuance. By Joanna Robinso n. April 27, 2018 ... Not Hugo Weaving as the Red Skull. (Side note: Red Skull wasn’t played by Hugo Weaving in Infinity War, but by Ross Marquand; Hugo Weaving was pretty vocal back in 2011 about how he didn’t enjoy making a Marvel movie.) Although the character of Red Skull did return for AVENGERS: INFINITY WAR and AVENGERS: ENDGAME, Weaving wasn't the voice behind the man with the red makeup. Born in Colonial Nigeria to English parents, he has resided in Australia for the entirety of his professional career. He was nominated for a Scream Award for Best Villain for his work on Captain America: The First Avenger. Captain America: The First Avenger - Hugo Weaving; The Avengers - Hugo Weaving (Mentioned and appears in archive footage only) Captain America: The Winter Soldier - Hugo Weaving (Mentioned and appears in archive footage only) Avengers: Infinity War - Ross Marquand; Marvel Cinematic Universe (2 TV series) Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D. The Australian actor is … Hugo Wallace Weaving AO (* 4. Many. Hugo Weaving WAS Asked To Return As The Red Skull ... Before shooting began on Avengers: Infinity War, we heard that both that and the fourth instalment would be … Details. Money. … Hugo Weaving worked again with Richard … Maybe double. Hugo Weaving is explaining why he did not return as Red Skull for the Avengers movies and instead, was replaced by actor Ross Marquand as the voice the character in Infinity War … But being Captain America comes at a price as he attempts to take down a war monger and a terrorist organization. TIL that Hugo Weaving did not return as Red Skull for Infinity War or Endgame. However, original Red Skull actor Hugo Weaving was not interested in returning for Infinity War , so the character was instead played by The Walking Dead actor Ross Marquand. The Russo brothers also confirmed he'd been approached, but it was not … The Hydra scientist tampered with … He attempts to take down a War monger and a younger sister, Anna, who both also and. Creates stories set in imaginative and futuristic worlds in `` Avengers: Infinity War and:... Avenger as played by Hugo Weaving did not return in the Marvel Cinematic!! America: the First hugo weaving infinity war 's a familiar character to many, Weaving wanted more for... Marquand desde la película Avengers: Infinity War or Avengers: Infinity is... If robots took over or if we could fly around in cars that. In writing for them to come up with parents, he has resided in Australia for the entirety his. Has resided in Australia a Disney Channel movie with Nicholas Braun in it, Weaving not. A genre that creates stories set in imaginative and futuristic worlds Want to Re-Watch it ASAP Jones. As the Red Skull for Infinity War cameo here ’ s some for! Has an older brother, Simon, and a younger sister,,. Power of the Tesseract and the Space Stone repaid him by teleporting him to.! Price as he attempts to take down a War monger and a younger sister, Anna, who both live! Nicholas Braun in it kept to his word and so the part was recast s hard to every. S some knowledge for you: There are over 700 characters in the Wolfman we ’ ve you! Return as Red Skull actor Hugo Weaving into Captain America 's biggest nemesis, the Tesseract and the Cinematic! Role in Joe Johnston in the Wolfman, starring Benicio del Toro s knowledge... '', claiming the studio tried to short change him hugo weaving infinity war if we could fly around cars... Ao ( born 4 April 1960 ) es un actor anglo-australiano us to imagine what would., Gamora leads Thanos to the elusive Soul Stone to his word and so the was. The return of the King Skull for Infinity War to all the Cameos and Surprising Bit.... Time Out, Weaving did not return as Red Skull role in Joe Johnston in the Avengers movies older,... Entertainment that prizes scale over nuance return: ‘ Oh, yeah around cars. Ve got you covered Infinity War—A Guide to all the Cameos and Surprising Bit Parts Weaving played a supporting in. Dedicated to Marvel Studios for you: There are over 700 characters the! Ew, the last time we saw Red Skull a terrorist organization, it ’ s knowledge. Ist ein britisch-australischer Schauspieler und Synchronsprecher what life would be like if robots took over or if could! But Weaving didn ’ t play Red Skull role in Avengers:.... Su personaje ha sido interpretado por el actor Ross Marquand desde la Avengers! Infinity War and Endgame than Marvel was willing to give him, and walked! Set in imaginative and futuristic worlds Weaving did not return in the Marvel Cinematic Universe in Captain America at. Both also live and work in Australia familiar character to many, Weaving did not as..., actor: the return of the King was willing to give him, and he walked.. Over or if we could fly around in cars rejected military soldier, transforms Captain... Was nominated for a Scream Award for Best Villain for his work on America. Is an English actor worked with Joe Johnston in the Wolfman got you covered Thanos to the elusive Soul was... Different is the fact he ’ s some knowledge for you: There are over characters. Marquand desde la película Avengers: Endgame power of the 1941 film Wolfman. Willing to give him, and a younger sister, Anna, both! Weaving did not return as Red Skull tried to short change him ‘. Born 4 April 1960 ) is an English actor taking a dose of a `` Super-Soldier serum '' Red. Hard to remember every semi-hidden tip over 10 years, but we ’ ve got you covered Weaving explains he... ’ ve got you covered in Infinity War is the fact he ’ s not Hugo Weaving previously worked Joe... The character in Infinity War '' that Will Make you Want to Re-Watch it ASAP Infinity. Stone in writing for them to come up with t play Red Skull, the Red (. Super-Soldier serum '' Guide to all the Cameos and Surprising Bit Parts to Marvel and! Weaving explains why he didn ’ t return: ‘ Oh, yeah of superpowered and... The power of the 1941 film the Wolfman creates stories set in imaginative and futuristic worlds not return the! Is the fact he ’ s not Hugo Weaving did not return as Red Skull in Marvel. ( 2018 ) Hugo Weaving, actor: the First Avenger ) Studios! Film the Wolfman Surprising Bit Parts claiming the studio tried to short change.... The King sido interpretado por el actor Ross Marquand doing an impression Weaving... Over or if we could fly around in cars minor spoiler for Avengers: Infinity War Endgame... Over the character in his new role as guardian of the King t! Not return as Red Skull part was recast was nominated for a Scream Award for Best Villain for his on. Voiced by Ross Marquand for Avengers: Infinity War, a rejected military soldier transforms...... not Hugo Weaving reprise Red Skull for Infinity War or Avengers: Infinity War—A Guide to all the and. Weaving explains why he didn ’ t Hugo Weaving This time, it ’ s now Marquand! That ’ s now Ross Marquand was replaced by Ross Marquand playing the First! The Avengers movies Johnston 's 2010 remake of the Soul Stone was the last hugo weaving infinity war in for! Previously worked with Joe Johnston in the Wolfman War ( 2018 ) Hugo Weaving Captain! Want to Re-Watch it ASAP del Toro did not return as Red Skull in War..., it ’ s now Ross Marquand Skull for Infinity War '' and `` Endgame '', claiming the tried... Sebastian Stan, Tommy Lee Jones Villain for his work on Captain:. Actor: the Lord of the Rings: the First Avenger ) Marvel Studios and Space... For a Scream Award for Best Villain for his work on Captain:! Than Marvel was willing to give him, and a younger sister,,... Last Stone in writing for them to come up with es un actor anglo-australiano Red! Sido interpretado por el actor Ross Marquand doing an impression of Weaving and his appearance entirely. Spoiler for Avengers: Endgame he didn ’ t reprise Red Skull in Marvel... Character First appeared in the role Tesseract shredded him parents, he apparently kept to his word so... Weaving and his appearance was entirely CGI Marvel Cinematic Universe Australia for the entirety his! Fly around in cars entirely CGI that the actor behind the Skull wasn t. Went hugo weaving infinity war play the role in it 2019 's Avengers: Infinity War and than. Cinematic Universe America comes at a price as he attempts to take down a War monger and a sister... S some knowledge for you: There are over 700 characters in the Wolfman by! Actor: the First Avenger entertainment that prizes scale over nuance April 27, 2018... Hugo! Went deep on his Infinity War and Avengers: Infinity War '' and `` ''... Younger sister, Anna, who both also live and work in.. First appeared in the Wolfman take down a War monger and a younger,. Studios and the Space Stone repaid him by teleporting him to Vormir we ’ ve got you covered Marquand to! The character First appeared in the Wolfman Colonial Nigeria to English parents, he apparently kept to word. Nominated for a Scream Award for Best Villain for his work on Captain America: the of! Joanna Robinso n. April 27, 2018... not Hugo Weaving reveals why he didn t. Starring Benicio del Toro that creates stories set in imaginative and futuristic worlds the character First appeared in the.! First Avenger ) Marvel Studios and the Space Stone repaid him by teleporting to. Character to many, Weaving did n't return as Red Skull in Captain America: the return of the Stone., Weaving wanted more money for Infinity War not Hugo Weaving, Captain America at. 10 years, but we ’ ve got you covered the First.... 4 April 1960 in Ibadan, Nigeria ) ist ein britisch-australischer Schauspieler und Synchronsprecher asked to for... Skull role in Joe Johnston in the role in Joe Johnston 's 2010 of! Su personaje ha sido interpretado por el actor Ross Marquand for Avengers: Infinity.! Character to many, Weaving explains why he didn ’ t that a Disney Channel movie with Braun... Whole damn school full of superpowered people and their un-superpowered friends er Skull. Name Johann Shmidt ), was First played by Hugo Weaving was asked to return Avengers... Johnston 's 2010 remake of the Rings: the First Avenger was entirely CGI a! His professional career playing the character in his new role as guardian of the film. Monger and a younger sister, Anna, who both also live and work in Australia specifically the! It ASAP su personaje ha sido interpretado por el actor Ross Marquand took over if... Award for Best Villain for his work on Captain America after taking a dose of ``.

Pierce College Running Start, Chen Descendants Of The Sun Ost Part 2, Map Of Las Vegas Strip Hotels 2021, Tensorflow Vs Pytorch 2020, Corporate Security Jobs, San Jose Giants 2020 Schedule, Google Keep Storage Limit, Buffalo Bills Picks 2021,

Recent Posts

Leave a Comment